I was a guest on CBC’s Day 6 program talking about the F-35 stealth fighter and Canada — and how the dream of a “universal” stealth fighter ran afoul of the unforgiving realities of time, cost and engineering.
7 Responses to “CBC’s Day 6: How the F-35 Dream Unraveled”
Leave a Reply
Search
Contributors
Written by
- David Axe
- Andrew Balcombe
- Kevin Knodell
- Steve Weintz
- Robert Beckhusen
- Peter Doerrie
Illustrated by
- Matt Bors
- Greg Scott
By the Contributors
Tags
Afghanistan
Africa
Air Force
Army
Boeing
China
comics
Congo
David Axe
drone
drones
Europe
F-22
F-35
France
Haiti
Iran
J-20
Japan
Joseph Kony
Latin America
Libya
Lockheed Martin
LRA
Marines
Matt Bors
Mexico
Navy
North Korea
Northrop Grumman
Pakistan
Paktika
pirates
police
Robots
Russia
Somalia
Southeast Asia
space
Special Forces
stealth
The Netherlands
U.N.
UAV
war
Blogroll
Archives
- May 2013 (21)
- April 2013 (11)
- March 2013 (16)
- February 2013 (19)
- January 2013 (25)
- December 2012 (26)
- November 2012 (28)
- October 2012 (27)
- September 2012 (33)
- August 2012 (33)
- July 2012 (35)
- June 2012 (43)
- May 2012 (55)
- April 2012 (43)
- March 2012 (64)
- February 2012 (46)
- January 2012 (36)
- December 2011 (48)
- November 2011 (39)
- October 2011 (52)
- September 2011 (49)
- August 2011 (38)
- July 2011 (50)
- June 2011 (45)
- May 2011 (54)
- April 2011 (51)
- March 2011 (75)
- February 2011 (67)
- January 2011 (57)
- December 2010 (55)
- November 2010 (76)
- October 2010 (60)
- September 2010 (87)
- August 2010 (86)
- July 2010 (62)
- June 2010 (75)
- May 2010 (74)
- April 2010 (73)
- March 2010 (76)
- February 2010 (97)
- January 2010 (116)
- December 2009 (70)
- November 2009 (69)
- October 2009 (58)
- September 2009 (69)
- August 2009 (55)
- July 2009 (59)
- June 2009 (89)
- May 2009 (90)
- April 2009 (91)
- March 2009 (84)
- February 2009 (69)
- January 2009 (48)
- December 2008 (33)
- November 2008 (28)
- October 2008 (44)
- September 2008 (35)
- August 2008 (38)
- July 2008 (30)
- June 2008 (41)
- May 2008 (38)
- April 2008 (49)
- March 2008 (48)
- February 2008 (37)
- January 2008 (28)
- December 2007 (28)
- November 2007 (40)
- October 2007 (32)
- September 2007 (39)
- August 2007 (53)
- July 2007 (42)
- June 2007 (48)
- May 2007 (55)
- April 2007 (54)
- March 2007 (58)
- February 2007 (38)
- January 2007 (30)
- September 600 (1)
Recommended Reading
Sponsors
Categories
- Accidents (43)
- Accountability (51)
- Afghanistan (681)
- Afghanistan 2012 (27)
- Africa (697)
- Africa Partnership Station (20)
- Africa Round-Up (16)
- Air (733)
- Alliances (115)
- Americas (112)
- Andrew Balcombe (48)
- AOL (21)
- Arctic (3)
- Asia (297)
- Atlantic Round-Up (44)
- Atlantic Sentinel (14)
- Axe in Afghanistan '07 (21)
- Axe in Afghanistan '09 (40)
- Axe in Afghanistan '10 (49)
- Axe in Afghanistan '11 (27)
- Axe in Chad (39)
- Axe in Congo (29)
- Axe in East Timor (12)
- Axe in Iraq '07 (5)
- Axe in Nicaragua (15)
- Axe in Somalia (18)
- Axe on C-SPAN (9)
- Axe on Donald Cook (21)
- Axe vs. Pirates (16)
- Ballistic Missiles (27)
- Biochem (3)
- Bizarre (20)
- Blog Business (50)
- Bombs (31)
- Bryan William Jones (21)
- Budget (15)
- C-SPAN (2)
- Chad (2)
- China (148)
- Coast Guard (7)
- COIN (75)
- Combat Aircraft (3)
- Comics (342)
- Commonwealth (4)
- Conflict Briefs (11)
- Congo (91)
- Conspiracy (7)
- Cyberspace (10)
- David Axe (1696)
- Defense Update (2)
- Denmark (1)
- Diplomacy (55)
- Drug War (23)
- East Timor (43)
- Elections (2)
- Europe (56)
- Extremists (83)
- Far East Round-Up (4)
- Finances (48)
- France (15)
- Greg Scott (2)
- Haiti (16)
- Health (32)
- History (47)
- Hugo Chavez (5)
- Ideas (17)
- India (16)
- Industry (161)
- Infantry (49)
- Inter-Service Rivalry (25)
- Iran (44)
- Iraq (185)
- Israel (11)
- Japan (79)
- Japan Security Watch (17)
- Jason Reich (25)
- Jessica Stone (2)
- Jonathan Hughes (3)
- Kevin in the UAE (9)
- Kevin Knodell (38)
- Kevin's Links (2)
- Kim Jong Il (11)
- Kyle Mizokami (277)
- Kyle's Links (263)
- Latin America (72)
- Latin America Round-Up (49)
- Lebanon (11)
- Legal (5)
- Libya (13)
- Logistics (58)
- Lord's Resistance Army (40)
- Marines (21)
- Matt Bors (177)
- Media Spin (5)
- Medical (34)
- Mercenaries (17)
- Mexico (33)
- Molly Brenan (6)
- NATO (9)
- Nature (48)
- Naval (634)
- Naxals (7)
- NGOs (19)
- Nick Ottens (9)
- North Korea (23)
- Nuclear (22)
- Pakistan (40)
- Palestine (1)
- Personal (61)
- Pete Doerrie (13)
- Peter Vine (54)
- Piracy (165)
- Police (62)
- Politics (151)
- Pork (4)
- Reality Check (77)
- Reconstruction (33)
- Refugees (25)
- Reich in Afghanistan (14)
- Relief (121)
- Reporters (153)
- Research (43)
- Robert Beckhusen (124)
- Robots (250)
- Royal Navy (6)
- Russia (71)
- Ryan Alexander-Tanner (3)
- Sam Abrams (61)
- Sam in Indonesia (10)
- Secrecy (30)
- Serbia (1)
- Smart Power (4)
- Soft Power (6)
- Somalia (73)
- South Korea (5)
- Southeast Asia Round-Up (20)
- Southern Partnership Station (45)
- Space (75)
- Special Forces (49)
- Stealth (66)
- Steve Weintz (31)
- Sudan (5)
- Syria (8)
- Ted Rall (2)
- Testing (30)
- The Diplomat (80)
- The Netherlands (34)
- Things with Wings (4)
- Top War Tech (9)
- Train like You Fight (9)
- Training (121)
- U.K. (22)
- U.N. Dispatch (17)
- U.N. Peacekeeping (102)
- Una in Afghanistan (21)
- Una Moore (47)
- Uncategorized (13)
- USNS Comfort (12)
- USS Toledo (9)
- Vehicles (63)
- Voice of America (15)
- War Stories (2)
- War Watch (6)
- Warships International Fleet Review (8)
- Waste (2)
- WIB Reads (19)
- Wired (331)
- Word Bubble (13)
- World Politics Review (29)
- Zach in Afghanistan (17)
- Zach Rosenberg (34)
























You’ve inadvertantly left out the F-35′s correct W.I.B. nomenclature.
Edit: …talking about the F-35 [Trillion-Dollar] stealth fighter and Canada…
Here we go again, the famous sports-car/dumptruck model that is having problems. If someone would admit that you are trying to design a single aircraft to do 10 different jobs. It has been designed by a committee to do a lot of things, the problem is the compromises you have to make to get all those jobs done with the ‘common aircraft.’ The simple truth that is still there is that all the ‘legacy airframes’ that the F-35 is supposed to replace are wearing out and very very rarely in any country is there a real replacement for them anywhere in the world.
Good points. I was so relieved to know no Canadian order had been signed in 2010 so I could watch the whole fantasy come apart over the next couple of years. Now it’s time to pull out the popcorn.
For the U.S., the tale is somewhat more tragic.
Autoplayed audio. Most annoying. Rapidly checked through three tabs trying to find the ‘video’ making the noise. Closing tabs one by one told my your blog was at FAULT. I listened anyway. Clicked to leave a comment, oh great, autoplay kicks in again & I’m forced to download the audio again becuase theres no “Stop Download” option. I’m going to think twice before clicking to your blog in future.
Post a comment, Autoplay kicks in AGAIN!
Sorry you were so annoyed. We’ll miss your visits.
Wow, you guys have a press that asks questions, we do not have that here in USA.
The last time they tried this it was the F-111, it was supposed to be a do all/end all miracle & all it could do was be a pretty good bomber.
I am doing all I can to ask hard questions & get the F-35 cancelled.
FA-18, F-16 or F16XL and F-20 are all cheap & we know how much they cost.
BTW the F-20 in 1985 was gonna go for $15,000,000 half the price of an F-16.
Thanks for the time & effort & the audio sounded fine.