The Diplomat: Can Afghanistan Help Itself?


Categorie: Afghanistan, Axe in Afghanistan '10, David Axe |

Via The Diplomat.


A pair of Afghan helicopters swoop down onto a farmer’s field in Mahageer, outside the city of Bagram, and disgorge squads of Afghan commandos carrying free radios and school supplies for local residents. It’s only a training event, with a small humanitarian component, but its narrow scope belies the mission’s importance — it is one of the first times that Afghan soldiers and pilots have worked together on an operation planned by Afghan officers, with no NATO input.

In Salang, the capital of Parwan Province just north of Bagram, a U.S. Army patrol, part of the NATO International Security Assistance Force, arrives for a visit with Gov. Abdul Basir Salangi. In February, Salang suffered a devastating series of avalanches that killed nearly 200 people. NATO helped Afghan forces rescue thousands of people from the snow. Now the Americans want to know what Salangi is doing to prevent such huge death tolls in future disasters. What they learn is perhaps both unsurprising, and deeply discouraging.

And at a village just a few hundred yards from the NATO airfield in Bagram, another U.S. patrol is looking for a man with a plan. Col. Marion Peterson, an Army agricultural expert, has come to put the finishing touches on a plan to build an irrigation system for the village’s parched vineyards. He sits down with a man named Wali, a medical doctor and farmer who also serves as the village’s chief engineer. Peterson is pleasantly surprised when Dr. Wali presents him with a fat stack of paperwork — everything the Army will need to secure foreign funding and local contractors for the irrigation project. It’s a rare display of what the Americans call “ownership.”

The three events, all of which took place in the span of ten days in mid-March, illustrate a profound problem in Afghanistan, as well as the best solutions for it. They’re also indicative of a wider issue that arises whenever foreign powers attempt to boost developing or war-torn societies — broadly, how do wealthy nations assist poor or war-torn countries without turning them into permanent dependents? And in Afghanistan’s case, this means the question is how can NATO help prepare Afghan society to look after itself, so that NATO can declare victory and leave?

Read the rest at The Diplomat.

Axeghanistan ‘10: A River Ran through It
Axeghanistan ‘10: Making Do in Parwan
Axeghanistan ‘10: Parwan Patrol Video
Axeghanistan ‘10: Air Bridge Video
Axeghanistan ‘10: Easier by the Day
Axeghanistan ‘10: Moon Shot
Axeghanistan ‘10: Down Side of the Surge
Axeghanistan ‘10: “Now You Know More than You Did Five Minutes Ago”


One Response to “The Diplomat: Can Afghanistan Help Itself?”

  1. @max1mos111 says:

    hellicopter training for the police and swat forces (not the Pak region) is allready a game plan for the long term withdrawl of US troops and NATO allies. A suggestion on my part today to @HSPI experts is to put some of the airbases up near the maountains tips. The cause is because UBL and his dominions occupy this region of earth. I feel the Afghan police in training should get a feel also for ORV’s in some of these regions occupyable at high altitudes so they can adapt to high altitude training. Ex. Colorado SF forces get the training to go high altitude and carry the right gear for up there.


Leave a Reply