Axeghanistan ’09: Op Donkey Haul


Categorie: Afghanistan, Axe in Afghanistan '09, COIN, David Axe |

It was a war we thought we’d won. But after eight years of escalating violence, the Afghanistan conflict has morphed into something perhaps unwinnable. U.S.-led forces invaded Afghanistan in 2001 to deny sanctuary to Al Qaeda, a goal we’ve largely achieved. But in years of occupation, Washington has apparently conflated counter-terrorism with nation-building. Now the U.S., NATO and their allies are struggling to destroy a deeply-rooted insurgency in country with a corrupt, ineffective government, poor infrastructure and few prospects for everyday people, but to fight. David Axe visits U.S. forces to see for himself.



Able Troop, 3rd Squadron, 71st Cavalry, part of the 10th Mountain Division deployed to Logar province, 50 miles south of Kabul, is way too small to cover the entire district of Baraki Barak, where its Combat Outpost is located. So the company uses observation posts, strung out along the district’s mountain peaks, to keep an eye things between patrols. Each OP is outfitted with sensors, rockets, machine guns and, most importantly, radios for relaying sightings of Talibs or other dushman.

It was October 16, and the OP on spur near Route Georgia needed a generator to keep all this equipment running around the clock. It wasn’t quite enough to warrant calling in a Chinook helicopter from Bagram. Instead, the job of hauling a 300-pound generator up a 1,000-foot, 30-degree slope fell to 3rd Platoon, the “Dirty Dingos,” who promise that “the Dirty Dingos get it done.” Someone had the bright idea of using the generator delivery to improve relations with the local residents. 3rd Platoon was allocated $100 — a month’s wage to most Afghans — to rent a donkey for the day.

Everything looked great on paper. They’d meet the donkey and its handler at the base of the hill, tie a sled to the donkey, place the generator on the sled, and escort the beast and its burden up the hill. Should take an hour, estimated Sergeant First Class Donald Coleman, the platoon sergeant. But this is Afghanistan, where nothing goes as planned.

The first sign that Operation Donkey Haul might prove an, ahem, pain in the ass, was a low, muttered, “Uh oh,” from the platoon interpreter, Z. There were apparently two donkeys available for the job — a good one and a “sick” one, to use Z’s descriptor. Wouldn’t you know it: the handler showed up with the sick animal.

So began a comedy of errors, illustrated below, that demonstrated perfectly the challenges of conducting a counter-insurgency campaign in rough terrain, with limited resources:


OP Spur, seen from below.


Our cast of characters.


Donkey, meet generator.


The donkey strains to pull the sled.


Progress is good until the road runs out.


Halfway up the slope, the donkey quits.


3rd Platoon decides to CARRY the generator the rest of the way.


For an hour, the soldiers take turns carrying the generator.


It’s Specialist Ryan Pascual’s job to hook up the generator once it arrives.


At the OP, Sergeant First Class Donald Coleman praises his soldiers.

What should have taken an hour, ended up taking two. Pascual hooked up the generator, turned it over to make sure it worked, and everyone sucked water then headed back down the hill. Halfway down, the OP radioed down: the generator had died. So Pascual climbed back up the hill, where he remained the rest of the day, tinkering with the finicky machine. Trudging back to their trucks, the rest of 3rd Platoon could only shake their heads. The Dirty Dingos get it done, but whoever was supposed to maintain the frickin’ generator sure dropped the ball.

(Photos: David Axe)

How to Bomb Nice
Cargo Jam!
Afghan Pirate Radio Defies Morale Crackdown
Special Delivery
Chopper-Bombing Drone-Killer
Saving Razia
Birds, Beware
Rescuers Re-Rescue the Rescued
Tale of Three Districts
Chicken & Egg
With Friends Like These
Interpreting Pashtunwali
Farmers’ Powwow


10 Responses to “Axeghanistan ’09: Op Donkey Haul”

  1. David M says:

    The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the blog post From the Front: 11/03/2009 News and Personal dispatches from the front and the home front.

  2. Dan A says:

    Maybe a better option is to pay the donkey handler to get the generator up the hill, instead of renting the donkey?

  3. I take it no one involved (save maybe the donkey handler) grew up on a farm. You can’t really force a donkey to do anything. You can try…

  4. Ghostrnd says:

    Do you really think that kid could carry the generator up the hill? Getting anyone in the local area is most likely difficult.

  5. Probably true. Too bad there wasn’t something with wheels that could have been pulled from the front and pushed from the back. 300 lbs is a lot for a donkey that size, even if it’s being cooperative.

  6. Steve W says:

    Um, it’s a generator, right? Could you get a guy at the base machine shop to bang out an electric-powered sled? A metal frame, a couple of motors, some tires and wiring; strap the package together for delivery? Auction off the sled after installation to the highest local bidder, or retrieve it on the next delivery?

  7. ghostrnd73 says:

    All great ideas but there was no time for great ideas or else they would have just waited for the helo to carry it for them.

  8. [...] In the early days of the Afghanistan war, U.S. Special Forces famously rode horses into battle. In Logar province this fall, the U.S. Army hired mule handlers to help haul cargo up mountainsides. The horse and its relatives still makes sense on modern battlefields. “The most responsive and reliable form of sustainment I had in Afghanistan was hiring local animals,” said Patrick Kinser, a trainer at the Marine Corps’ Mountain Warfare Training Center in California. The Marines have reinvigorated training for handling horses and pack animals. [...]

  9. The Breeze says:

    Minus a handfull of comments, most of you are ridiculous. If those soldiers would’ve had access to something with wheels, don’t you think they would’ve used it? c’mon guys. Poor donkey carrying 300lbs. Poor 18-25-year-old men carrying a 300 lbs generator up a friggin’ mountain. Poor donkey? Those are brothers, sons, husbands…poor donkey? Use something with wheels? Great show of empathy…toward the donkey.

  10. [...] to move a 300-pound generator a quarter-mile up a steep slope to a hilltop observation post. For that demanding task, they calculated they would need just one small [...]

Leave a Reply