A Decade of East Timor Aid: Mostly Wasted

07.09.09

Categorie: David Axe, East Timor, NGOs, U.N. Peacekeeping |

by DAVID AXE

Ten years ago, Catholic East Timor voted to break away from Muslim Indonesia. Subsequent fighting killed hundreds and flattened the tiny country’s infrastructure. The U.N., plus Australian and New Zealand peacekeepers, stepped in to provide security and funnel aid to East Timor’s 1 million people. But just 10 percent of the $8 billion provided by foreign donors has been spent at the local level. The rest has been wasted on “foreign security forces, consultants and administration, among other things,” according to a new Associated Press investigation.

The result is that “roads are in disrepair, there is little access to clean water or health services, and the capital is littered with abandoned, burned-out buildings where the homeless squat.”

East Timor was supposed to be a model example of from-scratch U.N. nation-building. Instead, the country has turned into a permanent welfare case, much like Chad and other Central African countries. U.N. proponents can point to much-reduced levels of violence in East Timor, but all other indicators point the wrong way. Unemployment is at 50 percent, families are still having too many babies, and the country’s theoretically-rich mineral reserves are not bringing in much revenue.

That’s the Catch-22 of foreign aid. In the short term, it saves lives. In the long term, it endangers them by creating countries wholly dependent on fickle aid donations. Because they never develop robust infrastructure, financial systems and human capital, aid-dependent countries are actually more prone to the very sort of calamities that caused them to become aid-dependent in the first place. But allowing countries to learn from, and evolve out of, their initial calamities is politically unpalatable to the developed world. We can’t stand the sight of starving babies and burning villages. And who can blame us?

(Photo: David Axe)

Related:
East Timor Security Reform Stalls
Wasteful East Timor Cries Help
Japan Hearts East Timor; East Timor Hearts Cash
East Timor “at Risk of Anarchy”

|

3 Responses to “A Decade of East Timor Aid: Mostly Wasted”

  1. Prestwick says:

    Well, thats what happens when you reserve large chunks of aid to ferrying NGO execs and staff around and house them in the lap of luxury. Out of every pound that Oxfam raise, barely 20p goes to the people who need it, the other 80p goes on “admin” which is weasel talk for “plush central London offices, advertising and business class flights…”

  2. Cynic says:

    The mistake people make is thinking it is aid for the people of timor. It’s not. It’s aid for the western military and corporate welfare. You don’t honestly think we care about poor starving brown people do you? Get real. And If they didn’t have oil / minerals which we might get at on the cheap, we wouldn’t even take a second look.

  3. [...] Related: A Decade of East Timor Aid: Mostly Wasted East Timor Security Reform Stalls Wasteful East Timor Cries Help Japan Hearts East Timor; East Timor Hearts Cash East Timor “at Risk of Anarchy” No Comments so far Leave a comment RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI Leave a comment Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> [...]

Leave a Reply